Litigation Archives - Vincent Young

Commercial Construction Litigation

10 July, 2024

Making a Calderbank Offer: Things to keep in mind

If you have ever litigated, you may have received a Calderbank Offer. The Calderbank Offer may have prompted you to question whether a bad settlement is better than pursuing a costly trial and the risks of losing the case and paying costs on an indemnity basis. The judgment in Metricon…

Victoria Caldwell

Adjudication Building Construction Litigation Security of Payments

10 July, 2024

Can Contractors Prove Their SOPA Losses When a Precise Calculation Cannot Be Performed?

The case of Canterbury Bankstown Council v General Works and Construction Pty Ltd NSWSC 310 This article deals with whether submissions have been duly made under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) (Act) and what is necessary to establish losses where a precise calculation cannot…

Victoria Caldwell

Commercial Construction Insolvency Litigation Security of Payments

5 April, 2024

Enforcing SOPA judgments: An overview of Garnishee Orders and Statutory Demands

Congratulations! You have just obtained an adjudication certificate. What comes next if the respondent refuses to pay the adjudicated amount? Knowing how to enforce SOPA debts is essential for construction industry participants who want to exercise their right to receive progress payment. Two potentially powerful options available to claimants are…

Victoria Caldwell

Litigation

28 March, 2024

The Question: Will The Court Order A Separate Question?

Typically, the standard approach in litigation is to resolve all issues together in a single hearing. However, there are exceptions acknowledged by the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) (UCPR) where a specific issue may be decided as a separate question before addressing the remaining disputes in the legal proceedings.…

Victoria Caldwell

Commercial Insolvency Litigation

8 March, 2024

Personal Liability of Administrators

The personal liability arising under Division 9 of Part 5.3 A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Act) often provides one of the greatest risks facing administrators on accepting an appointment. These risks can limit restructuring options available through a voluntary administration as an administrator is unlikely to want to…

Victoria Caldwell

Commercial Insolvency Litigation

29 February, 2024

Substituting Creditors – Why You Should Join A Winding Up Petition

What you need to know Where a company that owes you money is subject to a winding up application brought by an unrelated third party, you should always seek to join the proceedings as a supporting creditor. If you are a supporting creditor, you have a right to apply to…

Victoria Caldwell

Adjudication Building Construction Litigation

30 November, 2023

Procedural Fairness In Adjudication

Demex Pty Ltd v McNab Building Services Pty Ltd NSWCA 261 The recent NSW Court of Appeal decision in McNab Building Services Pty Ltd v Demex Pty Ltd NSWCA 261 considered an appeal of a NSW Supreme Court decision quashing an Adjudicator’s decision under the Building and Construction Industry Security…

Victoria Caldwell

Building Construction Contracts Development Litigation Projects

10 November, 2023

Recourse To Security Based On A Bona Fide Claim

Total Construction Pty Ltd v Catholic Healthcare Limited NSWSC 585 It is common for bank guarantees (BGs) to be used as a form of security to secure the performance of a contractor’s obligation in a construction contract. A principal’s right to have recourse to the BGs is often governed by…

Victoria Caldwell

Insolvency Litigation

22 September, 2023

Recovery of judgment debts – Garnishee and Writs

If you have obtained a judgment in your favour and the judgment debtor has failed to pay the judgment amount to you, what are your options? This article looks at two ways you can enforcement a judgment: a garnishee order and a writ. Garnishee order A garnishee order imposes an…

Vincent Young

Litigation Property

1 June, 2023

Clawback of incentives remains an issue

The clawback of incentives and their enforceability remains a live issue with the courts treating clawback clauses as a penalty in certain circumstances. This was recently reinforced in Alamdo Holdings Pty Ltd v Croc’s Franchising Pty Ltd (No 2) NSWSC 60 (Alamdo). In the context of commercial leasing, consideration should be given…

bluesix

Litigation

Categories

Archives